Generative Remove in Lightroom deep dive

Colin Smith

Subscribe on YouTube:

Things you may not know about Generative Remove in Lightroom

Lets take a deeper look into Generative Remove in Lightroom Classic. It works exactly the same in Camera Raw.

If you can’t upgrade Lightroom see this

Here is a photo with lots of extra people in it. Let’s remove them.

Generative Remove Lightroom Classic

Object aware

Turn on Generative ai and Object aware from the Remove panel.

Lightroom Remove panel with the eraser mode and Generative AI and Object Aware checked

Scribble select the man in the corner

Scribble selection drawn around a man in a black cap in the corner of the frame

Because Object aware is on, the scribble select becomes a nice selection. You want to go over the boundaries a little with Gen remove.

Man in the corner detected in red by Object Aware in Lightroom

When you apply, it removes the man nicely

Dirt ground with the man in the corner removed by Generative Remove

Skip the Refine Panel

Scribble select while holding down the Ctrl/Cmd key to skip Refine

Scribble selection around a photographer in a black shirt on a western town street

Now this man is instantly removed.

Western town street with the photographer instantly removed beside a man in a red bandana

Because the resolution is 1024 x 1024 larger removals will leave a softer background. (1024 x 1024 is 3.5 inches at 300ppi)

Softer patch of dirt circled in red where a large removal lost detail

You can use the stamp tool to fix the softer patch area, this is a lot easier now the ai removal has already taken place.

Clone stamp source and target areas on the dirt road to fix the softer patch

Variations

For the next removal, select the group of people in the left. Notice a potential problem; the back half of the dog os behind the group. What will happen?

Group of people at the left of the western street highlighted in red for removal

Generative Remove, removes the people and generates the back half of the dog. So it is capable of generating things.

Click the variations button to cycle between 3 variations.

Choose “Refresh” if you don’t like any of the variations. Unlike Photoshop, Lightroom only holds 3 variations at a time. You can choose the history panel and access the other variations though.

Western street with the group removed, leaving the man in the red bandana and his dog

Multiple ai patches at once

Notice the photo has raindrops on the lens. This would have rendered the photo useless in the past. With Generative Remove, we can now save the photo.

Chicago street at dusk with raindrops on the lens circled in red

Turn off Object aware for this task

Lightroom Remove panel with Generative AI on and Object Aware unchecked

Use the [ and ] bracket keys to adjust the size of the brush.

Apply the brush to both rain drops.

Two raindrop spots on the Chicago photo painted in red for Generative Remove

Notice they are nicely removed.

Chicago street at dusk with the raindrops removed from the lens

If you look, you will see that 2 pins have been created. Each of the spots has aplied its own instance of Generative Remove. This means that each spot gets its own variations, as well as not sharing a large area with one fill which will limit the resolution.

Two remove pins circled in red on the Chicago photo, one for each spot

Each spot has its own 3 variations to choose from.

Chicago photo with the variations control highlighted in the Lightroom Remove panel

Generative ai and Masks

Lets remove these people from an image that has already been editing with masks.

Gazebo on a cliff above the ocean at sunset with people under it, already edited with masks

Select the people and apply the Generative Remove tool

People under the gazebo highlighted in red for Generative Remove

Notice the people are removed, but it leaves behind artifacts.

This is because Gen Remove is working off the original image pixels.

People removed from under the gazebo, leaving a lighter unmasked patch outlined

The solution to to apply Generative remove at the beginning of the workflow.

If you have images that you already used masks on, not problem.

Click the ellipses menu and choose Update al masks.

Lightroom Masks panel menu with Update AI Masks highlighted

The mask updates and now it looks nice.

Gazebo at sunset over the ocean with the people removed and the masks updated

I hope you enjoyed this deeper look in the new Generative Remove in Lightroom.

For more on the new features in this release (13.3) check out this tutorial

Great to see you here at the CAFE

 

Colin


Follow along for more tips

Recommended for this tutorial

Learn Masks in Lightroom and Camera RAW

Make precise local adjustments in Lightroom and Camera Raw with every type of mask.

$59.99 · one-time purchase · instant download

Photoshop Vault: free Layer Blend Modes ebook, actions, brushes, presets and cheat sheets

Free for you

The Photoshop Vault

Get my free Layer Blending Modes ebook along with dozens of exclusive Photoshop goodies: actions, brushes, presets and cheat sheets.

You're on the list, so your free goodies are waiting for you in the Vault.

Get Free Photoshop Goodies Open the Vault

15 comments

  1. Jon Haverstick

    Fantastic, as always, Colin! I struggle with figuring out the best way to backtrack through gen-remove (other than ⌘-Z), so the history panel (which I never use) was a great reminder! Thank you for always keeping us on the cutting edge!

  2. I noticed, in the last image, when you updated masks that the plants in the lower right were darkened. What do you attribute that to?

    1. Colin Smith Author

      It rebuilt the mask and redefined that as the outline, easy enough to refine the mask if you prefer it the other way

  3. Rohinton Mehta

    Absolutely great.
    But I have a problem using it on my Mac Mini Pro 2. When I try to use the Remove Tool, I get a message, “Can’t use the Remove Tool because your system is running Rosetta”. Can you please help? (I have purchased quite some videos from you).

    1. Colin Smith Author

      Sounds like its looking for Apple Silicon M1+ chip

  4. Leonard Modderman

    Love your videos and the fact you have it in writing as well. Clear, concise and well laid out. Thanks you.

  5. Dan Umberger

    Colin, very helpful information – thanks.
    By the way, every time I watch one of your videos, I get an email with this message: “We received a request to change your subscription preferences. If you would like to change your preferences, use the link below.” Maybe others are getting these messages, too?

  6. Always enjoy and find useful your presentations. Many thanks

  7. Paul Lasky

    I have an Apple M2 Studio with 34 cores. Using LrC and the Remove Tool + “Object Aware”, I get specious and
    inconsistent results. For example I cannot remove a colorful picture with a wood frame on a mid gray wall. The application results in an ugly smear which requires a a painful time consuming fix. As a result I start with the Image in PS, clean it up there using layers and AI. Only after I finish retouching do I export back to LrC with an ,jpg image ( so that I avoid the usual PS/LrC transition annoying color shift.

  8. Marlene Schonbrun

    I always learn something useful from your videos and appreciate your efforts to create these videos and share your amazing knowledge.

  9. Rick V

    Always something extra in explanations from you – many thanks.

  10. Love it and also the way, you speak to us! I’m still a beginner, your videos help a lot. Thank you so much, Colin!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Copy link