Access Lightroom Adjustments inside Photoshop. Opens Smart Objects as Layers

Colin Smith

Subscribe on YouTube:

New In April 2023 update in Lightroom Classic 12.3 is the ability to open Multiple images in Photoshop Layers as Smart Objects. This is Huge because it now means we have way more flexibility in editing composites without losing access to the original Lightroom edits, ever! I’m going to show you the workflow here and point out some useful features as well as pitfalls to avoid. You might want to bookmark this page, because I’ll outline my workflow, which I think is the best possible workflow for using Lightroom and Photoshop together. Check out the short video, which shows all this in detail as well as how to choose different versions of Photoshop to use with Lightroom.

Opening Multiple Images in Photoshop as Layers

Make your initial edits in Lightroom

Choose multiple files from Lightroom. For this example, we will just use 2 images. You can choose more if you want.

Two aerial drone photos, a catamaran DNG and a coral reef dock JPG, selected in Lightroom Classic

Right Click and choose Edit in> Open As Smart Object Layers In Photoshop.

Lightroom Classic right-click Edit In menu with the Photoshop and plugin options listed

Open as Smart Object Layers in Photoshop highlighted in the Lightroom Edit In menu

Photoshop will launch and you will see a single document and each photo is opened as a Smart Object in a layer. (Learn about Smart Objects here)

Catamaran and coral reef drone photos opened as smart object layers in one Photoshop document

You know its a Smart Object because of the icon on the layer.

Smart object icon on the catamaran layer thumbnail in the Photoshop Layers panel

These  have the advantage of containing all the Lightroom Adjustments inside the raw file which is contained in the Smart Object.

Smart Objects diagram showing Lightroom Classic adjustments carried into a Photoshop smart object

Double Click the Smart Object Thumbnail to open it in Camera Raw.

Double-clicking the DJI_0698.DNG smart object thumbnail in Photoshop to open it in Camera Raw

Camera Raw will launch with the image from your layer showing.

Catamaran drone photo opened in Camera Raw from the Photoshop smart object layer

This image that opened is the Original RAW file from Lightroom. If you look at the adjustments, all the Lightroom adjustments are visible. All the sliders, masks and adjustments are preserved and can be changed in Camera Raw.

Lightroom Classic Basic panel settings matching the Camera Raw sliders for the same raw file

Even the crop settings are preserved. Here we will change the crop and even rotate the image, to show the flexibility

Click OK to apply.

Camera Raw crop overlay on the catamaran photo, showing the Lightroom crop was kept

Camera Raw closes and the Photoshop document updates to show the changes.

Photoshop document updated with the catamaran layer over the coral reef dock photo

Lets hide the background on the boat. You will probably make different adjustments, I want you to observe the Lightroom and Photoshop Integration, this is the purpose of this tutorial.

Choose Adjustment layers and select Blending Options

Blending Options chosen from the fx menu in the Photoshop Layers panel for the catamaran layer

Change the sliders on “Current Layer”. Drag the shadows to the right to hide the dark background pixels. Hold down alt/option and drag on the triangle to split it. How to use Blend IF to hide a Background in Photoshop

Layer Style Blend If sliders split to hide the dark water around the catamaran over the reef

Back to Lightroom with the Photoshop Adjustments

When you have finished making edits in Photoshop, choose Save. Or press Ctrl/Cmd+S

As soon as you save, a new image (tif) is created and automatically added to Lightroom. (The location of the tif will be in the same folder as the original photo).

Lightroom Classic Library grid with the new TIFF from Photoshop added next to the originals

If you want to make any further edits to this new image, it’s best to make the edits in Photoshop and Camera Raw.

The first time you opened the file, you opened as a Smart Object. When you saved it, its now a Layered file with the Smart Objects inside.

Re-edit diagram: the TIFF from Photoshop in Lightroom Classic opens back in Photoshop

Right-Click and choose Edit in>Edit in Photoshop

Edit in Adobe Photoshop 2023 chosen from the Edit In menu in Lightroom Classic

A window will appear.

Choose Edit Original.

Edit Photo with Adobe Photoshop 2023 dialog with Edit Original selected

Now Photoshop will open

All your layers are still there and your Photoshop edits are intact. All your Lightroom and Camera RAW edits are in the Smart Objects. You would Double-Click the thumbnails to open in Camera Raw just as before.

Layered file reopened in Photoshop with the catamaran and reef layers still intact

Create Nested Smart Objects for Global adjustments

The cool thing about Smart Objects is that we can combine multiple Smart Objects into new ones. This is called nesting.

Let me introduce you to a couple of terms to help. Adobe doesn’t officially use these terms, but I think they should.

Parent: The parent Smart Object, is the top level. All other Smart Objects can be nested inside the parent.

Child: All the Smart Objects that are within the Parent.

This allows us to apply adjustments to the entire image including all the layers. You can even apply presets, and all the edits, even the old ones are still accessible. Non-destructive. Let me show you here.

Nested Smart Objects diagram showing two smart objects placed inside one parent smart object

Choose Both Layers

Both smart object layers, DJI_0698.DNG and DJI_0619.JPG, selected in the Photoshop Layers panel

Right-Click and choose Convert to Smart Object.

Convert to Smart Object chosen from the right-click menu in the Photoshop Layers panel

Now you just see a single Smart Object. This didn’t merge the previous 2 layers, it just tucked them away inside the Smart Object. (A new Parent is created, with 2 Child Smart Objects inside)

Think of a smart object as a container. So you just put 2 containers (children) inside a bigger container (Parent).

Layers panel with one smart object holding the two nested layers, with a caption explaining it

To apply an adjustment, we need to choose Filter>Camera Raw. (If you double-click on the thumbnail you will expand the Smart Object. More on that soon.)

Photoshop Filter menu with Camera Raw Filter highlighted, over the drone photo of the catamaran

Camera Raw will open and you can make adjustments. In this case, I applied a Preset.

Camera Raw Filter with a preset applied to the nested smart object of the catamaran and reef

Click ok and you go back to Photoshop. Notice the Adjustments have been applied.

Catamaran and reef composite back in Photoshop with the Camera Raw adjustments applied

Notice the Camera Raw adjustments appear as Smart Filters. You can use almost any filter you want in Photoshop, most of the Filters work as Smart Filters.

Click the eyeball next to Smart Filters, to turn the adjustments on or off.

To edit the adjustment, click the icon in the lower right of the Layers panel.

Camera Raw Filter listed as a Smart Filter with the blending options icon in the Layers panel

Blending Options will show up.

Adjust the opacity to lower the intensity of the camera Raw adjustments (the preset).

Press ok.

Blending Options dialog for the Camera Raw Filter with opacity lowered to 57 percent

How to Access the original adjustments in a nested Smart Object

To access the original (Child) Smart objects or layers from within a (Parent) nested Smart Object, double-click the thumbnail.

The smart object will open inside a new tab

Nested smart object contents opened in a new Photoshop tab, pointed out with a blue arrow

Click on the tab and you will see the original contents are now revealed and ready for editing.

Double click either of these and Camera RAW will open and all the settings will still be there, as before.

Original DNG and JPG smart object layers revealed inside the nested smart object tab

When you are finished, choose save.You can now close the tab.

The parent Smart Object will now be updated.

Choose Save again in the main Document.

Diagram showing that saving in Photoshop creates a new TIFF that updates in Lightroom Classic

The Lightroom preview will now be updated to reflect any changes.

Lightroom Classic Library showing the updated preview of the edited catamaran TIFF

I hope you found this tutorial useful.  If you are still confused in any way, please check out the video at the top, it explains things in a very easy to understand way.

Next step is to check out my other tutorials on the new Lightroom updates.

Lightroom Classic New Features

I have made a series of tutorials on the newest Lightroom features. Check out these other Lightroom 2023 Tutorials.

What’s new in Lightroom 12.3
Curves in Masks in Lightroom

Denoise in Lightroom
Open Multiple images as Smart Object layers from Lightroom to Photoshop

If you want to really Learn Lightroom, check out my new Lightroom 2023 For Digital Photographers Course here 

Lightroom Classic 2023 for Digital Photographers course by Colin Smith with a sunset harbor background

If you want to really Adobe Camera RAW, check out my new Adobe Camera Raw 2023 For Digital Photographers Course here 

Adobe Camera Raw for Digital Photographers 2023 Edition course cover by Colin Smith

(These courses are how I fund everything here at the CAFE, notice that there are no ads)

Great to see you here at the CAFE

Colin


Follow along for more tips

Recommended for this tutorial

Learn Masks in Lightroom and Camera RAW

Make precise local adjustments in Lightroom and Camera Raw with every type of mask.

$59.99 · one-time purchase · instant download

Photoshop Vault: free Layer Blend Modes ebook, actions, brushes, presets and cheat sheets

Free for you

The Photoshop Vault

Get my free Layer Blending Modes ebook along with dozens of exclusive Photoshop goodies: actions, brushes, presets and cheat sheets.

You're on the list, so your free goodies are waiting for you in the Vault.

Get Free Photoshop Goodies Open the Vault

9 comments

  1. Rick Thompson

    Good day
    After watching your YouTube production I am unable to find the place to change the version of Photoshop I wish to open. When I go to the upper left hand corner of the program I cannot get a menu to drop down which allows me to change the settings. What am I doing wrong?

  2. Ron Pankey

    Colin,
    Excellent tutorial on a better marriage between LR and PS. However, I can’t get but one version of PS to show under External Editing as a selection. It’s always the last one I’ve installed, either PS or PS(Beta). Any ideas?
    Thanks,
    Ron

  3. Ron Pankey

    I hear from the Community that this is a window issue and not a Mac.

  4. :Lyle Hofstedt

    My setting do not open like yours does..and under preferances inLRC I onily have on(1) option “Photoshop Elements”
    which I do not have,,so bascially they have taken away my abaility to Edit in Phpotoshop option on right click?
    I Have the ability to edit in Affinity? whats goin on

  5. waheath88

    Thanks for the tutorial. However, when I open the photo as a smart object from LR, I am blocked from using the spot healing brush or any of the other healing tools. When I enter the photo from LR as a normal photo, I have no problem using any of the tools. What am I missing? Thanks.

  6. Lynette Kent

    Again – wonderfully explained from a true educator!!!

    Thanks, Colin

  7. Chris

    This was helpful. I get it but will need to practice. Do you routinely use smart objects when you are editing a single layer in Photoshop.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Copy link