Week- 4 - fotodog v joe roe ( Voting closed)

[jusu]

Subject: Create a cartoon cell

Theme:

Instructions:It can either be hand drawn or converted from a photo or use of another progam is allowed as long as 50% photoshop work is involved.

Normal sizes apply

[Edited on 1/2/2007 by jusu]

[Edited on 1/5/2007 by jusu]

[Edited on 1/7/2007 by jusu]

[Edited on 1/9/2007 by jusu]

[Edited on 1/9/2007 by jusu]

[jusu]

Current score:

home - away
/9/____/7/


Voter__________Voted on Home (H) / / Voted on Away (A)

(H) - PNeal
(H) - Hrc
(H) - uk2usadaz
(A) - padiq
(A) - Hermie
(H ) - Solo
(H) - loky
(H) - Josh
(A) - Ranjit Nepal
(H) - PM
(H ) - paradox
(H) - rayvolvez
(A) - jusu
(A) - Hannu
(A) - Martha
(A) - JMe


[Edited on 1/5/2007 by jusu]

[Edited on 1/5/2007 by jusu]

[Edited on 1/6/2007 by jusu]

[Edited on 7-1-2007 by uk2usadaz]

[Edited on 1/9/2007 by jusu]

[Edited on 1/9/2007 by jusu]

[fotodog]

Here is my entry - Bill the superhero


http://angelpix.20m.com/fotodog/battle_ground/bill_superhero_sm.gif

Link to larger image (http://angelpix.20m.com/fotodog/battle_ground/bill_superhero.gif)

[joe roe]

Heres mine

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v701/Joe_Roe/week4copy1.jpg

[rAyVoLvEz]

fotodog gets my vote..

cell = handphone? :lol

[Tat]

Joe Roe Gets Mine! I Thought It Was Funny! Lol!

[jusu]

Originally posted by Tat
Joe Roe Gets Mine! I Thought It Was Funny! Lol!

Only member of league can vote:)

[ranjit_nepal]

I go for joe roe! cose it's funny and look cartoon-ner than that of jusu.

[rAyVoLvEz]

Originally posted by ranjit_nepal
I go for joe roe! cose it's funny and look cartoon-ner than that of jusu.

u mean fotodog (Greg)? jusu is only against pm this week..

[Hermie]

Joe Roe gets my vote. It's a though desision.

Fotodog - I really like the details, the clouds, the cape (it's not really fitting in), the sky and bill's face.
The text is hard to read.
Joe Roe - I like your man and woman. There funny and really looking great (that's why you get my vote), the background is not really fitting in, the house is to small, as also the tree. Not to say the sun is bigger in his proportion....

[padiq]

joe roe gets my vote....

the human cartoon detail is realyl good....the background is not that great but its funny so thats why joe roe gets my vote.... THe other one is good....fotodog...but it seems empty--it is funny though.....if we was in a city of high rise buildings instead of a desert or garden then u would have maybe got my vote..:cool::cool::cool::cool:

[Hannu]

joe roe looks more cartoony to me.

[Solo]

joe roe im very curiouse how did make this one?? illustrator??is it really u who made it? looks quite professional ;) not that i doubt ur skills, but havent seen soo good pics (illustrations) on this site :D

[jusu]

Originally posted by Solo
joe roe im very curiouse how did make this one?? illustrator??is it really u who made it? looks quite professional ;) not that i doubt ur skills, but havent seen soo good pics (illustrations) on this site :D

Just to clarify, are you voting joe roe or just asking him a question?

[Hrc]

Tough one for sure, but ill go for fotodog cos i like the style.

[joe roe]

Hi solo

I started with a setch scaned them into ps and coloured them

heres one of the boy

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v701/Joe_Roe/boysketch.jpg

[Edited on 5/1/2007 by joe roe]

[PM]

fotodog !!
well detailed, the text makes it cool also...

:cheers for both!!!

[Edited on 1/5/2007 by PM]

[jusu]

joe roe

I like both works, they are decent works both of them. but guys, both backgrounds are a bit out..they dont really fit at least to my eye:)

[JMe]

I vote for joe roe, I prefer the style in general of fotodogs, but Joe's was more cartoon and comic strip like. Both funny ;)

[PNeal]

Vote to fotodog

joe - your characters don't seem to fit with the background -- Different styles.

[Josh]

fotodog...nice style...something like vector art...but joe roe's look a bit like those taken from colouring books...;)

[uk2usadaz]

Greg fotodog

[Marthig]

I like Fotodog's illustration very much it is nicely done and really looks like a dream image ...

... but JoeRoe's gets my vote as it does look like a cartoon cell, I agree about the background not really seeming to "belong" but the important items are the two human characters, and it is really funny (in a scary way :lol )

[Solo]

i dont vote yet..have to double check it ;)

[loky]

I go for FOTODOG

[paradox]

fotodog

[Solo]

fotodog ;)