Week 1 MakeUp Battle : Gankstah versus Hrc (Awaiting cfire)

[rAyVoLvEz]

Subject : Logo Design

Theme : Black Versus White

Instructions :
Design a logo for Black vs White. You can present it anyway you like. With a photograph in a collage of some sort going with the theme. on a board wherever you want to throw it.

[Edited on 12/30/2006 by rAyVoLvEz]

[Edited on 12/31/2006 by rAyVoLvEz]

[Edited on 12/31/2006 by rAyVoLvEz]

[Edited on 12/31/2006 by rAyVoLvEz]

[rAyVoLvEz]

Week 1 Make Up - Gankstah vs Hrc


Current score:

home - away
/2/____/10/ --> Winner is Hrc


Voter__________Voted on Home (H) / / Voted on Away (A)

(A) - PNeal
(A) - uk2usadaz
(A) - Hermie
(_) - cfire
(A) - loky
(A) - joe roe
(A) - Josh
(A) - fotodog
(A) - PM
(H) - paradox
(A) - rayvolvez
(H) - jusu
(A) - Hannu (Lewisel)

Above 13 voters to vote, to maintain fairness for week1 voters number.

[Edited on 31-12-2006 by uk2usadaz]

[Edited on 12/31/2006 by rAyVoLvEz]

[Edited on 12/31/2006 by rAyVoLvEz]

[Edited on 12/31/2006 by rAyVoLvEz]

[Gankstah]

http://www.endyoursearch.com/wvb2.jpg

higher res aviable at
http://www.endyoursearch.com/wvb.jpg

Photoshop. Picture of cat from adobe stock photo. Manipulated for presentation. 1/2 inspired from the concept of rays meow cat. I was working on the logo for awhile it felt clumped. I than decided to use 2 fonts in the logo which is something i normally do not do unless its needed for hierarchy. Im very proud with the outcome. Cant wait to see what my buddy put together. =0.

[Solo]

i love cats so i love this one :) lets see the opponents shot :)

[Hrc]

Very interesting chalenge because logo designing is totaly out of my domain so it was great oportunity to explore this side of designing.
Here it is. Source photo is from sxc.hu. :cheers

http://img183.imageshack.us/img183/7/bvswtv7.jpg

[Solo]

Hrc very good, but i ll vote later..have to look trought the pix once again ;)

[rAyVoLvEz]

Hrc gets my vote. Although Gankstah won in presentation, Hrc won with the logo by a nose hair..

[jusu]

Thats pretty hard to make difference between these two, both are pretty good. i was wondering what might be the context where these works could be used. Gankstah`s is more like a fine package for wine bottle, Hrc`s might be something for business, this is 50/50, but Gankstah get my vote for a bit more clear presentation:)

[PM]

my vote goes to Hrc!
Gankstah's e really cool, but i think Hrc's has more that versus, fight, feeling...

only cos of that, cos its really hard to decide...

:cheers

[fotodog]

This was a tough one.

But when I see logo as the end goal here, I have to vote for HRC by a whisker (sorry for the pun)

Gankstah, your's is very nice and powerful. But I see yours more as packaging rather than a logo. A logo should be universal in presentation and form. Your's tends to be a bit limited here.

Great battle!

:cheers:notworthy:cheers

[Hermie]

Hrc get's my vote....

Like PM sad, it gives me more the feeling of a "fight". What i don't like is the grey!! Without it is was better.

Gankstah - I like the idea, and if you changed the color of the cat, on the black side, to white, you've won...

[uk2usadaz]

Tough one.

Hrc by whisker.

[loky]

I would chose HRC's because in my oppinion a logo must be ... simple but in the same time to express what's all about. Gankstah's is very nice to, but not in a logo cathegory I would say. Great job to both.!

[Solo]

wow thanks god i cant vote...its a hard one :D

[PNeal]

Hrc

[Hannu]

For the reasons mentioned above, Hrc.

[joe roe]

I vote for Hrc

[ranjit_nepal]

I vote for Hrc.

[paradox]

ganks

[Josh]

hrc